If 

HISTORICAL  AND   LINGUISTIC  STUDIES  IN 

LITERATURE  RELATED  TO  THE 

NEW  TESTAMENT 


FIRST  SERIES— VOLUME  II,   PART  5 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS 


By 
EDGAR  J.  GOODSPEED,  Ph.D. 

Professor  of  Biblical  and  Patristic  Greek 
The  University  of  Chicago 


THE  UNIVERSITY  OF  CHICAGO  PRESS    .  U: 

CHICAGO,  ILLINOIS 

THE  BAKER  &  TAYLOR  COMPANY,   New  York 

THE  J.   K.   GILL  COMPANY,  Portland,  Oregon 

THE  CUNNINGHAM,  CURTISS  &  WELCH  COMPANY,  Los  Angeles 

THE  CAMBRIDGE  UNIVERSITY  PRESS,  London  and  Edinburgh 

THE  MARUZEN-KABUSHIKI-KAISHA,  Tokyo,  Osaka,  Kyoto,  Fukuoka,  Sendai 

THE  MISSION   BOOK  COMPANY,  Shanghai 


The  Department  of  New  Testament  and  Early  Christian  Literature  issues, 
from  time  to  time,  Historical  and  Linguistic  Studies  in  Literature  Related  to  the 
New  Testament.  These  studies  are  grouped  in  three  series :  I,  Texts ;  II, 
Linguistic  and  Exegetical  Studies;  III,  Historical  Studies.  The  volumes  in 
each  series  are  issued  in  parts. 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS 


Kf  Trpo*rHc; 


IIOH- 


O  u^-  <v^  ou  ouijj  tu  aiu  •  aiif  oaf 


g*   - 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS:  MATT,  i  :  i-4a 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS 


BY 


EDGAR  J.  GOODSPEED 

PROFESSOR  OF  BIBLICAL  AND  PATRISTIC  GREEK 
THE  UNIVERSITY  OF  CHICAGO 


THE  UNIVERSITY  OF  CHICAGO  PRESS 
CHICAGO,  ILLINOIS 


0 


Copyright  19 18  By 
The  University  of  Chicago 


All  Rights  Reserved 


Published  January  1918 


Composed  and  Printed  By 

The  University  of  Chicago  Press 

Chicago,  Illinois,  U.S.A. 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS 

In  1895  the  University  of  Chicago,  through  Professors  E.  D. 
Burton  and  C.  R.  Gregory,  secured  a  manuscript  of  the  Gospels  in 
Greek,  which  was  deposited  in  the  Haskell  Oriental  Museum  of  the 
University.  It  was  transferred  in  191 2  to  the  Manuscript  Room  of 
the  Harper  Memorial  Library,  where  it  now  is.  The  manuscript  had 
come  to  Chicago  in  the  hands  of  a  Greek,  from  whose  estate  it  was 
purchased.  It  dates  from  about  1500  a.d.  and  is  written  in  a  large, 
round  cursive.  It  now  contains  267  leaves,  but  originally  its  forty 
quires,  the  last  of  seven  leaves,  with  the  eleven  leaves  of  prefatory 
material,  must  have  made  at  least  330  leaves.  Of  these  quires 
twenty-nine  are  still  complete  (I-III,  V-XIV,  XXIV-XXXI, 
XXXIII-XL),  four  lack  one  or  two  leaves  (IV,  XV,  XVI,  XXXII), 
and  seven  (XVII-XXIII)  are  quite  gone.  The  quires  are  num- 
bered on  the  lower  inner  corner  of  the  first  recto  and  last  verso. 
The  leaves  measure  18  by  26.5  or  27  cm.,  and  are  inscribed  in 
single  columns  n. 3-1 1.8  by  17.8  cm.,  with  19  lines  to  a  column. 
There  are  some  ornamental  headings  (Matthew,  Mark)  and  a  few 
initial  capitals.  The  parchment  is  often  stiff  and  thick,  though  it 
is  very  uneven  in  quality.  The  hand  is  large,  round,  and  regular, 
and  much  of  it  had  been  traced  over  in  late  ink.  The  parchment 
was  ruled  in  the  usual  manner,  the  writing  depending  from  the  line. 
There  are  the  usual  accents,  breathings,  and  punctuation  marks; 
t-subscript  is  generally  lacking.  The  lesson  and  chapter  titles  in 
the  margin  are  usually  in  red,  as  are  the  Eusebian  section  and  canon 
numbers.  There  are  no  paragraphs.  The  manuscript  is  No.  46 
(Gr.  2)  in  the  Catalogue  of  Manuscripts  in  the  Libraries  of  the  Uni- 
versity of  Chicago,  and  is  fully  described  in  that  work,  pp.  49-51. 
A  quire  (6  ff .)  from  a  thirteenth-century  Greek  lectionary,  which 
has  been  united  with  the  Haskell  Gospels  in  binding,  is  also 
described  there,  No.  50  (Gr.  6),  pp.  55,  56.  In  Gregory's  catalogue 
(Textkritik  des  Neuen  Testamentes)  the  manuscript  appears  as  1290 
of  the  gospel  minuscules. 

The  eleven  leaves  preceding  the  first  quire  give  first  a  list  of 
lesson  titles  with  explanatory  paragraphs,  then  the  letter  of  Eusebius 
157]  5 


4SS819 


0  HISTORICAL  AND  LINGUISTIC  STUDIES 

to  Carpianus,  the  Eusebian  canons  in  red,  a  imifieais  tov  /caret 
Mardcuov  evayyekiov,  and  the  list  of  chapter  titles  for  Matthew. 
With  the  first  quire  Matthew's  Gospel  begins,  and  with  the  eleventh 
quire  it  ends.  A  virbdeo'is  tov  /card  Mapicov  ayiov  evayyeXiov  begins 
the  twelfth  quire,  and  is  followed  by  the  Gospel  of  Mark.  The 
concluding  chapters  of  Mark  and  the  opening  chapters  of  Luke, 
together  with  the  intervening  material,  are  missing.  Luke  is  fol- 
lowed by  a  vTrofxvrjfjia  els  tov  ayvov  airoo~To\ov  'Iccavvrjv  tov  deokbyov 
and  the  Gospel  of  John,  with  which  the  fortieth  quire  ends;  there 
are  no  subscriptions.  The  lacunae  in  the  Gospels  are  thus  Matt. 
9:36 — 10:10  (quire  IV,  f.  1),  12:156-2961  (IV,  8),  Mark  7:246-360 
(XV,  1),  9:486—10:140  (XVI,  1),  12:1— Luke  9:2  (XVI,  8,  and 
XVII-XXIII),  John  1 :  1-140  (XXXII,  1),  3 :  146-270  (XXXII,  8).1 
The  following  verses  stand  just  before  Matthew;  cf.  von  Soden, 
Die  Schrijten  des  Neuen  Testaments,  I,  p.  378: 

4  fACLTdaiov  To8e  epyov  apicrToirbvoio  Te\6)vov 
os  tokov  e<j>pao~e  Oetov  aireipoyapQio  yvvawbs: 
fj  T€K€  aawopov  vlbv  bv  ov  x^€V  ovpavbs  evpvs  • 
x(pi>o~TO)v  deifcWrcf  6{eb)v  ftpoTOV  ovtov  ebvTa.  -j. 

(f.  110) 

The  following  verses,  the  first  four  of  which  occur  not  infre- 
quently in  cursives  before  Mark  (cf .  The  Newberry  Gospels,  p.  7 ;  von 
Soden,  op.  cit.,  p.  378),  are  written,  not  in  verses,  but  as  though  they 
were  prose;  the  verse  divisions  are  here  indicated. 

oaaa  wept  xpto"Toto  derjybpos  edvea  irerpos  \ 
uripvaaaiv  ebibaaKev  airb  o~Top.a.TO)v 
epiTipiav,  I  evdabe  p.apnos  ayeipe  nai  ev 
ae\ibeo~o~Lv  edrjKe  •  \  Tovveica  mi  jxepb- 
irevaiv  evdyyekos  ctXXos  ebeixOy- —  | 
epyov  apnrpewes  en  fieyakov  irerpov 
pvrjdels,  I  judp/cos  erev^e  Tobe  irv(evp,aTo)s 
ev  aocpir]: — : — :— : — : — : — 

(f.  990) 

1  Professor  Gregory,  loc.  cit.,  notes  lacunae  in  Mark  5:26-40  and  John  3:27-33, 
but  these  sections,  while  doubtless  missing  when  his  notes  were  made,  have  since  been 
recovered  and  reunited  with  the  manuscript. 

158 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS  7 

Of  these  verses,  1-4  appear  in  the  Newberry  Gospels;  the 
beginning  of  verse  5,  epyov  apnr penes  .  .  .  .  ,  von  Soden  reports  in 
e  184  {op.  cit.,  I,  p.  384,  No.  59).  The  paragraph  is  a  combina- 
tion of  two  sets  of  verses,  one  of  four  lines,  and  one  of  two,  in  honor 
of  Mark.  The  last  words  are  repeated  at  the  top  of  the  following 
page: 

4   epyov  apiTrpeires  en  p,eya\ov  irerpov  p.v- 

rjdels,  I  judp/cos  erev^e  robe  Trv(evp.aTo)s  ev  o~o<$>'u]\ 

(f-  99&) 

As  to  type  of  text,  the  readings  of  the  manuscript  are  rather 
markedly  Syrian.  Taking  Mark,  chaps.  1-5,  as  a  representative 
passage,  the  manuscript  shows  33  significant  divergences  from  the 
Received  Text.  Of  these,  3  are  singular  or  nearly  so,  and  may  be 
neglected.  Of  the  30  significant  supported  readings,  14,  or  46.7 
per  cent,  are  Syrian.  With  this  may  be  compared  the  figures  for 
Codex  Montfortianus  (61),  employed  by  Erasmus  for  the  text  of 
I  John  5:7  (the  Three  Heavenly  Witnesses),  in  his  edition  of  1522. 
This  manuscript,  which  is  believed  to  have  been  written  not  long 
before  that  date,  is  thus  almost  contemporary  with  the  Haskell 
Gospels.  Of  its  52  supported  significant  variations  from  the 
Received  Text  in  these  five  chapters  of  Mark,  21,  or  40.4  per  cent, 
are  Syrian.  The  Newberry  Gospels,  a  twelfth-  (according  to 
Gregory,  eleventh-)  century  cursive,  gives  a  Syrian  element  of  42  .9 
per  cent  for  the  same  section.  As  these  may  be  considered  fairly 
representative  Syrian  manuscripts,  the  Syrian  element  in  the  Has- 
kell Gospels  woukLseem  to  be  more  than  usually  large. 

This  collation  was  first  published  in  the  Journal  of  Biblical 
Literature,  XXI,  100-107,  in  1902.  Nevertheless  Professor  von 
Soden  in  19 10,  in  his  Die  Schriften  des  Neuen  Testaments,  I,  3, 
p.  2172,  describes  the  manuscript  as  "unerreichbar."  On  being  sent 
the  collation  in  19 13,  however,  he  assigned  the  manuscript,  which 
he  designates  e  586,  to  his  group  3>c,  and  associated  it  with  d  362 
and  with  €1091,  1098.  On  its  relationship  to  5  362  he  referred  to 
John  5:36;  13:18,  and  Luke  19:4,  8.  In  the  same  letter  (July  7, 
1 9 13)  Professor  von  Soden  gives  the  Toronto  Gospels  the  number 
€  1 1005  and  refers  it  to  his  Ka  type,  connecting  it  with  the  manu- 
scripts €  329,  e  1390. 

159 


8  HISTORICAL  AND  LINGUISTIC  STUDIES 

Matt,  i :  6     croXopcoya  pro  SoXopcoi'ra 

2:5     ourcos  pro  ovto)     11  elbov  pro  evpov     19  i}8ov  pro  idov 

3 : 6  iopbavyi  +  7rorapco  8  napirbv  a^tov  pro  napirovs  d£tous  9  +  ort 
ante  irarepa     11  —Kaiirvp'i 

4:1  tr .  avtixGy)  b 'la  10  iVa/ye  +  on-tcco  /xou  18  —  6  'I770-0US  [but 
in  the  margin  a  lectionary  phrase  in  a  late  hand  runs  r<3  /catpco  e/cetyco 
7rept7rarcoi>  6  '!?] 

5:12  —  oi5rw  7ap  eo'tcoijaj'  tovs  irpo(f>rjTas  tovs  too  vp,&v  16  ourcos 
pro  ovto)  19  ourcos  pro  ourco  20  Jr.  vpxav  rj  oinaioavvq  23  /cat  tnei 
pro  KCLKet  26  ov  pro  av  27  —rots  apx^ots  28  avTrjv  pro  avrrjs 
29  ftXrjdrjvai  pro  fiXrjdr]  39  els  />ro  eirl  40  tpdrioj>  +  cou  44  rots 
pnaovGiv  pro  tovs  ptcrowras  45  +  rots  #«te  ovpavots  46  iroiovaw  pro 
ttoiowi     47  c/>tXous  />r0  adeX<f>ovs 

6:1  7rpocrexer€  +  6c  6  rapttW  pro  raptetop  18  —ev  tu>  cfrapepco 
24  papco^a  pro  pappcom     25  evoweade  pro  evbhayade  \  irXelcov  pro  irXetbv 

7 : 2  p,€Tpr]dr)(r€Tai  pro  avTLfxeTpr)drjffeT(u  1 2  ourcos  ^>r0  ourco  |  ourcos 
/>ro  ouros  14  rt  />ro  on  15  eVcofe  pro  eaiadev  17  ourcos  pro  ovtco 
18  dware  pro  bvvarai 

8:2  irpoaeXd&p  pro  eXd&v  5  aurco  ^>ro  rco  'i^crou  8  Xoyco  pro 
Xbyov  11  avaKKrjdrjaovT at  pro  avaKXidrjaovTai  13  enaTovTapxy  Pro 
€KaToi>Tapx<*>  I  post  eKtivyj  +  /cat  vTrovrptyas  6  eKarbvrapxos  eis  rbv  oIkov 
avrov  ev  avrrj  tt)  copa,  evpe  top  iraWa  outov  vyuaivovTa  [avTrj  Trj  tr.  a 
man.  sec.?]     31  eicfiaXrjs  pro  e/c/SaXXeis 

9:4  €t6"cbs  pro  18 wp  13  dXXd  pro  aXX'  17  dpc/>6r€pot  pro  dpc/>6- 
repa  18  —  aurots  |  apx^v  +  ets  |  dXX'  />r#  dXXd  19  rjKoXovdrjoav 
pro  rjKo\ovdr]a€v     22  aur?7  ^ro  avTrjv     27  utds  j^ro  ute     33   —  ort 

9 :  36-10 :  10    amissis 

10:10     pafibovs  pro  pafibov     12  +  XeyovTes  dpi}vri  rco  ot/cco  rourco 

15  7r6Xr;  pro  ttoXu  19  XaX^cere  />ro  XaXrjarjTe  25  d7re/cdXe<raj'  ^>rc? 
e/cdXecraj>  |  ot/ceta/cous  ^>ro  ot/aa/cous  28  (frofirjode  pro  <f>ofir)drJTe  \  clto- 
KTevbvTcov  pro  airoKreivovTUv  |  +  ttjv  ante  \l/vxw2  \  +  r6  ante  crcopa2 
29  vpxbv  +  tov  iv  ovpavots     36  otKciaKot  pro  ot/aa/cot 

1 1 : 1     ereXeoe    pro    ereXecrev  \  —  6     I?;crous      2    'tu   />ro    Xptcrrou 

16  7rcuStots  pro  7rat6aptots  21  (3r}daa'Cda  pro  Brjdaa'idav  |  +  Kadrjp,evat 
ante  p,eT€vbr}oav 

12:6  nei^ov  pro  juet£"coj>  8  —/cat  156-29CI  amissis  29  Siap- 
Trdcrr;  />ro  hapTa.<Tti     32  €di>  ^ro  df1  |  rco  vvv  atcoj't  ^ro  rourco  re?  atco^t 

160 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS  9 

35  —rrjs  /capStas  42  croXopcows  pro  SoXopowros  bis  44  vTOcrrpexf/o} 
pro  ''Et'KKJTphpoi 

13:14  —  hr*  ■•  15  tdcropat  pro  idcrcap^ai  27  —  rd  28  <rvKhel-op,ev 
pro  avKke&pev  30  —  toj  33  eKpwf/ev  pro  eveupwpev  40  /caterat  pro 
icara/caterat- 

14:14  avTols  pro  aurous  19  —/cat2  22  dp  pro  ov  25—6  'I77- 
crous     27  <po(3r}crde  pro  (J>o(3el<rde     30  e/cpafe  ^ro  e/cpa£€ 

15:4  —  <rou  8  pi  />ro  pot  19  /cotXtas  />ro  /capStas  32  vrjaris 
pro  vrjareLS 

16:3  7rpcotas  />ro  7rpcot  |  bvvaade  +  Ywomt  12  om.  vs.  tot.,  suppl. 
in  margin.  17  +  6  awte  '1770-ous  28  dpi^  +  Se  |  &be  eor&Tes  pro  t&v 
&8e  icrTrjKOTdov 

17:4  pcocret  ^ro  Mcoo-77  7  (pofirjcrde  pro  (popeTofle  9  e/c  ^0  airo 
12  ovtcjs  pro  ovto}     14  avrdv  pro  avrS2    27  avafiaivovra  pro  avafiavra 

18:4  TaTreLvdocret,  pro  TaireLvaxrri  6  els  pro  etrl  9  —  oou1  12  eVe- 
vr\Kovr  aevvia  pro  evvevquovraevvea  13  evevrjKovT  aevvea  pro  evvevrjKov- 
t  aevvea  15  apaprrjaei,  pro  apaprrfar)  18  dpi)?'  +  5£  19  7rdXt*'  + 
dp?)i>  I  alrrjaovTat  pro  oxTr\aiAVTax  28  ei  rt  />ro  6  rt  29  —  iravra 
30  +  T17P  cm/e  <pv\aKrjv     31  iavr&p  pro  ovt&v     35  ourcos  />ro  ourco 

19:5  KoWrfdrjaeraL  pro  7rpoo7coXX?70i7crerat  8  ourcos  />ro  ourco 
9  —  «l  J  om.  potxdrat  /cat  6  air6Ke\vpAvqv  yaprjaas:  suppl.  man.  sec. 
12  ourcos  />ro  ourco  15  —  aurots  16  veavianos  rts  ^ro  ets  |  2r.  fl-oi^cco 
aYafldi'  |  £r.  £"co?)i>  auoviov  ex^  *9  "~ "ow1  21  ovpavois  pro  ovpavq 
24  elaeXdetv  pro  he\Qelv 

20 : 2  /cat  avpcjxovrjaas  pro  avp^navrjaas  be  3  —  ri)p  4  /cat  e'/cetwts 
/>ro  /cd/cetwts     21  evwvvpuv  +  cou     22  77  ^?ro  /cat     26  carat  />ro  ecrrco 

29  eiaropevopevov  clvtov  pro  eKiropevopevuv  avr&v 

21:1  firjdacpayri  pro  Brjd<payfj  3  d7rocrreXXet  ^ro  a7rocrr€Xet 
10,11  7rdcra  .  .  .  eheyov  sec.  man.  inlitura  14  tr.  xwXot  /cat  ruc/>Xot 
22   edf   />ro    df      24  eVepcor^crco    pro    ipwqo-oo      28   avBpwwos  -f-  rts 

30  erepco  />r0  bevripca  35  ebrjpav  pro  ebetpav  41  e/c5cbcrer at  />ro 
e/coocrerat     45   — ot3 

22:7  /cat  atcovaas  pro  d/coucras  5e  |  jSacrtXeus  +  e/cetws  13  //\  x€t- 
pas  /cat  7r65as  37  e</>77  pro  elirev  \  —rrj1  et2  39  avrr]  pro  carry  \  iav- 
tov  pro  aeavrbv     46  ribwaro  pro  ebvvaro 

23:3  eav  pro  av  |  Toiijre  pro  Troielre2  11  ecrrco  pro  ecrrat  13  —  5e 
18  av  pro  eav     21  KaroiKT\o' avri  pro  Karoirnvvri     25  ecrcofle  /?ro  eaudev  \ 

161 


10  HISTORICAL  AND  LINGUISTIC  STUDIES 

dot/ctas  pro  aKpaalas  27  ecrude  pro  laudev  28  ovrws  pro  ovtoo  |  eo-oide 
pro  eacodev  36  +  ort  ante  Tj^et  |  tr.  iravra  ravra  37  airoKTevovaa 
pro  cLTOKTeivovcra 

24: 2     tr.  ravra  iravra  \  ovk  pro  ov  /it)2     6  fxekfjaere  pro  MeXX^crere 

15  earcos  ^ro  eorta  17  ra  pro  tl  20  — eV  27  —/cat2  32  t'677  />ro 
77677  33  ourcos  />ro  outco  )  tr.  ravra  iravra  36  —  rrjs2  46  — aurou 
49  wow.  prim,  eadirj  5e  Kal  irivr)  pro  eo-dUtv  8e  Kal  Tiveip :  corr.  eo*0tet  8e 
Kal  irivei 

25:3  avrcav  pro  eauTco*'1  9  ov  jut)  pro  ovk  19  tr.  \byov  per' 
avrcov  26  77077s  prim,  man.;  corr.  77§ets  30  e/c/3dXeTe  pro  e/cjSdXXere 
44  —  aura) 

26:4  /r.  6oXco  KpaTrjawai  9  +  rots  aw/e  7rrcoxots  13  auT77  /w 
aux77  15  Kal  eyw  ^ro  /cayo)  17  iroipaaopiv  pro  eroipaawpiv  18  eort 
/>r0  corty  26  -tw  I  ei>xaPt0'ri70'as  ^W  evKoyrjaas  31  biaaKopTnadi]- 
crovTai  pro  8ia(TKop7riadr]<T€Tai  33  —Kal  |  eyco  -+*  oe  35  airapvqo'iopai. 
pro  awapirqaopai  |  6/iotcos  +  8e  36  irpoaevi-opai  pro  irpoaev^oipai 
38  atrots  +  6  'to-  40  Tore  pro  /cat1  |  aypvirvrjaai  pro  yprjyoprjaai 
43  /r.  ot  b<j>da\pol  avr&v  48  edy  ^ro  a?  52  airodavovvTai  pro  airo- 
\ovvrai  54  ovtcos  pro  ourco  59  tr.  davaT&o-oxnv  airrbv  70  epirpoadev 
+  airaV  7 1  aurots '  />r0  rots  74  /carafleiiaTtf eti/  />/*o  Karavadepari^eiv 
75   -rou2 

27:12  — tow2  28  eKdrjaavres  pro  eKhvaavres  29  a  ai'flcoj'  />ro 
amvd&v  [marg.  cap.  om.]  30  —  ets1  35  — fra  .  .  .  K\rjpov  41  7rpeor- 
6vT€pcop  -f-  /cat  4>apiaaio3v  42  +€77'  awte  aurco  43  -w  44  ai>r6j> 
£7*0  airco2     46  Xt/xd  />ro  Xa/zd  55— e/cet 

28:2  0upas  +  tov  pvqpelov  9  —6  10  /cat  e/cet  ^ro  /cd/cet 
19  —  ovv 

Marki:6    -{- 6 ante 'luavvris    14—6    15  TnarevaaTe pro Tncrnvere 

16  avTov-\-rov  aipaivos  20  piadoT&v  pro  piaQwdv  27  eaurous  pro 
avrovs  29  eto^Xflov  pro  rjkdov  3 1  air  77s  j&ro  avrols  34  aurdi'  + 
tcV  x*'*  ci^at  37  tr.  ere  ^rjTovai  38  /cat  e/cet  ^ro  /cd/cet  |  ZKrpXvda  pro 
e^tkifKvBa     44  /XCOUO-77S  pro  Majors. 

2:1  /r.  eto-^X^e  TrdXt^  7  ourcos  ^ro  ourco  |  et  pX  pro  et  jut) 
8  ourws  +  aurot     9  ow  />ro  cot     14  Xei/t  pro  K.evXv     26  —  tov 

3:12  /r.  (fjavepov  avrbv  17  ante  roi)  ta/ccb/3ou  marg.  add.  avrov 
27  ou5ets  bvvarai  pro  ov  Svvarai  ovdels  32  d5eX</>ot  o"ou  +  /cai  ai 
d6eX^>at  crou     33  /cat  />ro  77 

162 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS  11 

4:1  awr)xOv<Tav  Pr°  awrjxOr)  4  —  rod  ovpavov  8  ev  pro  ev  ter 
9  —  avrols  18  —ovto'l  eiaiv2  20  ev  pro  ev  ter  21  redrj  pro  eiriTedri 
30  bpouoaopev  pro  bpoi&acopev  {penult.  0  in  litura)  31  kokkov  pro 
kokkco  32  av&drj  pro  airapr}  \  pel^ov  pro  p.ei£uv  (0  in  litura)  33  &v~ 
vavro  pro  r\bbvavTo  37  \a?\ap\J/  prim.  man.  pro  XaiXaxf/  corr.  \ 
eirifiaXev  pro  eireftaXXev     40  ourcos  pro  ourco 

5:3  ebvvaro  pro  rjbvvaro  11  ra  opet,  pro  to,  opt]  13  elarjXdev 
pro  elafjXdov  \  upprjae  +  iraaa  [but  marked  for  erasure]  16  6177717- 
aavTO  be  pro  naX  birjyrjaavTo  19  TeiroirjKe  pro  eiroir]ae  26  avrfjs  pro 
eavrrjs     40  iravras  pro  airavras 

6:2  —  on  15  —  77  16—6  17  —  777  27  aweKovXaropa  pro 
<rjr€Kov\aTupa  29  —  rco  31  evuaipovv  pro  rjVKaipovv  33  — ot  6%Xot 
37  ayopaaopev  pro  ayopaaupev  \  tr.  brjvapicov  biaKoaiuv  44  —  cbcret 
45  airoXvaei  pro  airXovari  52  /r.  abr&v  17  Kapbla  53  yevvrjaaper  pro 
Yevqaaper 

7:4  xa^K€^1'  />P0  xaXKtwj'  5  paJdrjTats  pro  pad-qrai  15  e£co0e 
/>ro  efadev  18  ourcos  />ro  ourco  20  /r.  eKTopevopevov  etc  roO  'acou' 
21  ecxcode  pro  eaoidev  ?     24  — ri7i>     246-360  amissis 

8:3  Ferris  /vo  vfjCT  eis  \  riKOvai  pro  rj/catrt  13  —  to1  21  Xe'Yet 
/?ro  eXeyep  25  avefiXeipe  pro  evefiXexpe  26  —  w  31  +  t&v  ante 
apxiepeoov  j  +  t&v  ante  ypapparecov  35  ttjv  eavrov  ipvxw  pro  ttjv 
\f/vxvv  clvtov2     38  eav  pro  av 

9:2  —  rdv3  4  poovafj  pro  Mcocret  5  irovqaopev  pro  irovqaoopev  \ 
tr.  plav  rjXiav  6  \a\rjcrei,  pro  XaXrjari  7  —  \eyovaa  13  —  mi1 
18  —  d?  20  ibbv  proib&v  22  -f-  rd  tzwte  xup  |  a-woXeaei  pro  airoXeari 
25  +oaw^6xXos  26  tr.ToXXa  nai  34  birfXexdyvav  Pro  bieXex^^av 
41  —  rco    42  eay  ^ro  dv  |  pwpwv  +  tovtuv  [tu>p  pwp&v  tovtuv  in  litura] 

9 :  486-10 :  140  amissis 

10:14  —  Kal2  16  evXoyei  pro  -qvXbyei  17  aurco  pro  avrbv1 
21  —rots  24  —rots2  27  —  izavra  yap  bvvara  eari  xapa  rco  0eco 
28  T7p£aro  5e  ^>ro  /cat  rjp^aro  29  /cat  a7TOKpt0ets  />ro  aTOKpideis  be 
35  — ot  40  —pov2  43  ourcos  ^ro  ourco  |  /r.  ujucoy  bianovos  44  €af 
/>ro  d^  I  /r.  yeveordcu  vp&v  46+6  ante  uios  5 1  pa.fi fiovvi  pro 
'PaPfapi 

1 1 : 1  fi7)6cr<f)ayrj  pro  Bt]6(f>ayri  3  d7rocrrcXXet  ^ro  a7rocrreXet 
21  ei-rjparat.  pro  e^-qpavTai  22+0  aw/e  'I^crous  24  aiTrjade  pro 
alrelade     26  a^rjaei -\- vplv     29  ical  eyu  pro  Kay&     32   —  edy. 

163 


12  HISTORICAL  AND  LINGUISTIC  STUDIES 

Mk.  12:1 — Lk.  9:2  amissis. 

Luke  9:5  eap  pro  av  9  —6  |  raura  pro  rotaOra  10  tr.  eprjpop 
tottov  13  tr.vpets  avroXs  \  tr.  ixdves  dvo  \  pin  pro  prjTi  \  ayopaaopep 
pro  ayopaaoopep  15  oirrcos  pro  ovtoj  20—6  23  —  nad'  rjpepap 
24  eav  pro  av1  27  ecrroiTOip  pro  eaTrjKorwp  \  yevaoiPTai  pro  yevaoprat, 
28  cos  pro  coael  I  —  top  33  elTe  pro  eltrep  \  —6  \  Trotrjaopep  pro 
Toiyacopev  \  tr.  plav  pcoael  |  eXdXei  pro  Xe7et  35  tr.  eyevero  cpcoprj 
36—6  40  €K/3aXco<r«/  pro  eKfiaWctxnv  41  tr.  top  vIop  aov  &8e 
49  —ret     56  —  yap     62  tr.  6  \a  irpos  avrop 

10:2     h^aXr}    pro   eKfiaWr}     6   —  pep  |  —  eir'    avrop     8  —  t)j>  5' 

12  -de  13  x°Pa^'LV  Pr0  Xcopafb  20  —  paXKop  22  /r.  poi  irape- 
86Brj  27  eavrop  pro  aeavTOP  29  -\- 6  ante  irK^aiop  30  e^edvaap  pro 
endvaaPTes  32  avTnraprfKde  pro  avTnraprfKdep  34  eis  pro  eirl  36  /r. 
7tX?7guoj>  cWet  cot  39  [rtoi']  Xoycop  /w  top  \byop  [The  corner  of 
this  leaf — 144 — is  torn  away.] 

1 1 : 1  eirabaaPTO  pro  eiravaaro  5  Topeverat  pro  iropevaer ai 
6  —  /xou  8  oaop  pro  octup  9  evprja-qre  pro  ehpr\aere  10  apouxdy- 
oeTai  pro  avoiyqaerai     1 1   +  «£  #w/e  fyxcoi'     127}  .^ro  el  j  jut)2  -f-  icai 

13  /r.  bbpara  d^a^d  25  eXflco*'  />ro  eX^w  31  croXojuwws  />r0  S0X0- 
pdpTos  bis  32  pipevtrai  pro  Nweut  33  upvirTrjP  pro  kpvittop  \  fj  pro 
ovde  I  0cos  j^ro  (freyyos  40  eiroirjaep  pro  eiroiriae  44  —  oi2  49  5tco- 
%ovaip  pro  eiibu>i%ov<np     54  —/cat 

12:4  airoKrepoPTOip  pro  diroKreLPOPTcop  7  <j>ofir}ade  pro  (frofie'iade 
11  awoXoyrjaecrde  pro  airoXoyrjarjade  15  aurco  ^ro  airot)1  20  a<f>pop 
pro  "A<ppccp  22  epbbaeade  pro  epdvarjerde  23  +  ovxl  ante  rj  ipvxv  \ 
ivXeioiP  pro  irhelop  24  Taptelop  pro  rapelop  33  apeKXrjwTOP  man. 
sec.  38  oirrcos  pro  ovtco  45  rbireip  pro  Tvirreip  47  avrov  pro 
eavTov  48  aTraiTrjcrovcnp  pro  aiTi]aovaLP  50  —  5e  53  biapepLadrjaerai 
+  Tap  I  eiri  ^ro  e<£'  54  outcos  pro  ovtco  58  /3dXr7  ^ro  /3dXXfl  59  tcV 
/>ro  to 

13:6  tr.  $t)t&p  mpirop  8  Koirpia  pro  icoirpiap  14  depaireveadai 
prim,  man.;  -ade  man.  sec.  19  +  top,  ante  Krjirop  |  amov  pro  eavrov 
20  —  Kal  21  eupwpep  pro  epeicpvif/ep  29  —  a7rd2  |  LpaKk'qd'qaoPT ai 
pro  apaKkidi]aoPT ai  32  ibov-{-eyu  34  airoKTepovaa  pro  airoKTeipovaa 
35  —apijp  I  /r.  Xe'7co  5e 

14:5  ytos  pro  opos  \  —ep  8  /caraicXt^s  C0/T.  e  KaraKXrjdijs 
10    apairecai   pro   apaireaop   \   <rot3    prim.    man.    om.      12   —  Kat1 

164 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS  13 

15  apiarov  pro  aprov  24  post  8eiirvov  add.  in  marg.  tto\oI  yap  euri 
kXtjtoI  6X17701  5e  e/cXe/crot  26  avrov  pro  eavrov1  27  tr.  elvai  p.ov 
28  +  6  ante  6e\wv  \  els  pro  irpbs     32  tr.  iroppca  avrov 

15:4  evevrjKOvraevvea  pro  evvevrjKOVTaevvea  5  avrov  pro  eavrov 
6  ovyKoXetrai,  pro  ovyicaXel  7  ourcos  pro  ourco  |  evevrjKovraevvea 
pro  evvevr\mvraevvea  10  our  cos  pro  ourco  21  -\- iroirjcrov  pe  cbs 
eva  t&v  pwdiuv  aov  23  e^eveyKovres  pro  eveynavres  26  —  avrov  \ 
—  ravra 

16:1  -\-TravTa  ante  to.  3  OKairTrjv  pro  o-Kawreiv  5  avrov  pro 
eavrov  15  —ear iv  21  d7r€Xtx0J/  /f0  a,7reXetxo^  22  — rou  25  co5e 
/>ro  68e     26  eVfley  />ro  eVreufc*' 

17:4  —  eiri  ere  9  —  avrcf  10  our  cos  />ro  ourco  22  eiredvp/qaere 
pro  kK{BvpA\aere     24  —  /cat     26  —rou1     34  —  61 

18:5  inroine^rj  pro  vruwia£xi  7  Troirjarj  pro  -wovqaei  9  —  /cat1 
14  7}  -f-  yap     28—6  cm/e  irerpos     $$  rr\  rp'vrt]  rjpepa  pro  rrj  ripepa 

TJI  TpLTJI 

19:3  eoTiv  pro  tart  4  bpapoev  pro  TrpoSpap&v  \  81  om.  prim, 
man.;  suppl.  corr.  \  epeWe  pro  77/ieXXe  7  iravres  pro  airavres 
8  pxn  pro  pov  15  —  Kal2  16  /was  pro  pva  18  /was  pro  pva 
20  /t^as  pro  pva  23  —  r^p  29  $yfia<$>ayr\  pro  Byd^ayi}  \  —  avrov 
48  Troirjaovaiv  pro  Troirjacoaiv 

20:5  —ovv  9  —  rts  10  Srjpavres  pro  Seipavres  11  8rjpavres 
pro  Seipavres  19  -tw  Xadp  28  pcjvffijs  />ro  Mcocr^s  |  rts  pro  tlvos 
31  errd  +  Kai  35  [TJtjs  ex  m  litura  \  eKyapl^ovTai  pro  eKyapio- 
kovt ai    41  Xe'7oucrij/  pro  \eyovo~L 

21:2  tr.  nva  Kal  3  7rX€ta>  pro  irXelov  \  efiaXXev  prim.  man.  pro 
efiakev  6  —ov:  suppl.  man.  sec.  12  Trdi'rcoi'  pro  airavToov  16  tr. 
yovemv  Kal  avyyev&v  /cat  <f>l\o)v  Kal  a8e\<fxav  20  vro  +  raw  34  j3a- 
prjdGxnv  pro  fiapvvdGxnv     36  — raura 

22:4  —rots2  9  eTOLfj.ao-op.ev  pro  eroLpaaoopev  11  avor/aLov  pro 
av&yeov  23  ^  />ro  elf)  30  —  &  r^  fiaaikeia  pov  \  Kadiaeade  pro 
Kodlo-qade  31  e^r^craro  />ro  e^Tr\ffaTO  32  €/cXt7r?7  />ro  eKKelirrf 
34  (fruvrjaTi  pro  (fxavriaet  35  oWevos  pro  ov8evos  36  iroikqaei,  pro 
iroiXrjadTio  |  ayopaoei  pro  ayopaaaro)  42  -wape\delv  pro  irapeveyKelv 
45  — aurou  47  avrovs  pro  avr&v  52  xpds  />f0  eV  53  dXXd  ^ro 
dXX'  56  —/cat1  60  —  62  63  8alpovres  pro  8epovres  66  —  re  | 
ovt&v  pro  eavruv 

165 


14  HISTORICAL  AND  LINGUISTIC  STUDIES 

23:1  ijy  ay  ov  pro  tfy  ay  ev  12  —6  18  aveicpa£ av  pro  aveKpa^av  \ 
—  rbv  25  —  airroLS  26  —rod1  38+17  ante  einypa<t>r}  51  —  /cat2 
54  —/cat2     55   —  /cat1 

24:4  tr.  avbpes  bvo  18  —  eV  19  elxe  irpbs  avrovs  pro  elirev 
avrols  I  cos  pro  6s  24  ovtus  pro  ovna  36  -f-  /cat  cm/e  airds 
40  eSet^ep  pro  eTebet^ev  42  peKiaaeiov  pro  peXtomou  46  ourcos  />ro 
ourco 

John  1 : 1-140  amissis  28  firjdavia  pro  Brjdafiapa  29  —  6'Icodw77s 
prim.  man. :  sup  pi.  marg.  40  —  5e  42  p.ea'iav  pro  Mecratai'  |  —  6 
44  —6  'ItjcoDs  I  aurcG+o'tf    49  —6     51   -\- on  ante  elbov. 

2:1  H-eV  czwte  rrj  rjpepa  12  —  /cat  ot  padrjTal  avrov;  suppl.  man. 
sec.  (fxadarai)  14  —ev:  suppl.  man.  sec.  17  icara<t>ayerai  />r0 
Kare<f>aye  22  ekeye  pro'eKeyev  \  —  avrols  23  +  rots  cwfe  'lepoaoXv- 
juots  I  —  ai/roO2     24  xd^ra  pro  iravras 

3:4     —6     10  — 61     146-270  amissis    36  p^evei  pro  fxevei 

4:3  'IouSaiaf  +  777V  |  aTTJXdev  pro  airrjXde  |  —  tclKlv  5  o5i>  +  6 
'iT  13  — 61  20  //\  rco  opei  rovrco  21  X«7et  +  o5^  25  uecrtas  pro 
Mecrcrtas  35  rerpapT)vbs  pro  rerpdprjvbv  46  tr.  irakiv  6  'tf  |  r\(jQevt] 
pro  rjadevei     47  ep.ekke  pro  r/peXXe 

5 : 1  juera  +  5e  |  +  77  aw/e  eoprri  5  rpiawvra  /cat  6/crco  j>r0 
TpiaKovraoKTOi  7  j8dX?7  />ro  fiakkrj  10  eort  j^ro  ecm?  |  +  /cat  a«/e 
ou/c  21  ourcos  />f0  oirrco  35  aydWiadrjvai  pro  ayaXkiaadfjvat, 
36     TrKrjpwo-oo  pro  reXetcbaco     46  pcocrct  pro  McocttJ 

6:3  /r.  enadrjTO  e/cet  15  avex&pyaev  pro  avex&pr)cre  \  —  irakiv 
24  —/cat1  29  —6  30  —  ov  39  —  eV  40  -\-evanterrj  44  07r?7P 
ow.  man.  prim.;  suppl.  marg.  44  +  ev  ante  rrj  45  —  rod1  \ 
clkovuv  pro  cLKovaas  52  post  bovvai  add.  avrov  man.  sec.  58  ^rjaei 
pro  {-qaerai  62  Qeoipelre  pro  Oecopijre  68  —  aurcu  70—6  'ItjctoOs 
71  ep.ek.kev  pro  tfpekkev 

7:12  —  6e  16  aireKpidr)  +  ow  21—6  29  —  5e  31  jut)  ^0 
H"f]TL  32  77/couo-ai>  +  ow  |  tr.  virrjperas  ol  ^aptcratot  /cat  ot  dpxtcpe ts 
33  —  avrols  39  —  6  40  \6yov  +  rouroi'  41  —  be  52  ^05/  £717- 
yeprai  man.  rec.  add.  8:12  iw  marg.     53  dirrjkdov  pro  eiropevdt) 

8:1  /cat  6  'tf  />r0  'J^croOs  be  2  irakiv  +  fiadeos  \  rjkdev  6  'tT  ^0 
irapeyevero  3  —  irpbs  avrov  \  eiri  pro  ev  4  ct7roj>  />ro  Xt7oi;crtJ/  | 
ravrrjv  evpoptev  It'  auro^wpco  p,OLxevopevr]v  pro  avrrj  .  .  .  p.oixevop,evr] 
5  rip,o)v  p,a)wrjs  pro  MC00-77S  17^1^  |  Xt^df  eiv  pro  \ido(5o\eia6 ai  \  Xe7€ts+ 

166 


THE  HASKELL  GOSPELS  15 

irepl  avrijs  6  Karrjyopijaai  pro  Karr\yope1v  \  Kareypafav  pro  eyptupev  | 
yrjv  +  pr)  irpoo"KOi.ovp.evos  |  KaTqyoprjaai  .  .  .  icpoo-KOiovp.evos: 
atram.  alio  part,  in  litura  part,  in  marg.  7  eTepcorcovres  pro 
epwT&vres  |  avafSK&pas  pro  avaKv\f/as  \  elirev  avrols  pro  elire  irpos 
avrovs  I  —t6v  I  avrr)v  pro  avrrj  \  tr.  /3aXerco  eir'  avrr)v  9  —  /cat  vtto 
rrjs  avve(.hr)aeois  e\eyxbpevoi  \  tr.  6  'iT  povos  \  oxxra  pro  eorcocra 
10  elbev  avTr)v  /cat  el-ire  pro  /cat  p,rj5eva  dea.aap.evos  ir\r)v  rrjs  yvvawds 
elirev  avrrj  |  yvvai  pro  r)  yvvr)  \  —  eneZvoi  11+  aird  tov  vvv  ante 
p.f)KeTi  12  eKa\r\aev  pro  eXdX^cre  \  tr.  ehahr\o~ev  aurots  \  irepiTarrjar) 
pro  irepnraTrjaei.  14  r)  pro  /cat3  19  —  6  26  XaXco  pro  \eyco  44  + 
rod  ante  irarpos  52  yevarjTai  pro  yevaerai  53  av  sup  pi.  in  marg. 
man.  prim.     54  r)p&v  pro  vp&v 

9:3  —6  15  eiredrfKe  pro  eTedrjKev  \  tr.  p.ov  eirl  tovs  6<p6a\p,ovs 
20  dTeKpldrjaav  +  de  21  eavrov  pro  avrov  27  tr.  padrjTai  abrov 
28  —  ovv  29  pooaet  pro  Muarj  35  —  r/Kovaev  .  .  .  e£co  |  +6  'is* 
ante  elirev    36  +  nai  ante  t'ls 

10:4  €/c/3dXXet  pro  eKfiaKr)  8  —  irpdep,ov  13  p.e\\ei  prim,  man.; 
corr.  p.e\ei  22  —  -rots  23  —  tov  \  aoXopoovos  pro  SoXojuaWos  32  + 
/cat  aw/e  ota     39  —  ovv 

11:9  —6  I  irepLTaTel  pro  irepiTaTrj  20—6  21—17  31  KXau- 
cr€t  />ro  KKavarj  32  //*.  auroO  eis  rous  7r65as  ^^  —  KKalovaav 
48  outcos  pro  o'vto)  I  iriorevauiGiv  pro  "KiaTevGovviv     51—6     57  —/cat1 

12:2  avaKeip.ivuv  uvv  aurco  pro  avvavaKeip.ev<jov  avrw  6  ep.e\\ev 
pro  ep.e\ev  12  — 62  13  — 62  15  epxerat  +  crot  16  —6  20  —  e/c 
30—6     33  e/xeXXei'  ^ro  r}pe\\ev     34  — ort     50  ourcos  pro  pvto) 

13:8  +6  cmte  irerpos  12  7w  p.adrjTcov  pro  avr&v  18  €70?  + 
7<xp  25  eKelvos  +  outcos  33  />os/  punpov  add.  xpovov  man.  sec. 
36  67rou  +  ey<h     37   —6  awte  xerpos     38  (frcovrjari  pro  (pwvqaet 

14:3  erot/xdcrat  />ro  /cat  erotpdcrco  22  -f-  /cat  cmfe  rt  23  —  61 
23  TOir)o~o)p.ev  pro  TOir)<rop.ev     30  —tovtov     31  ovtojs  pro  ovrca 

15:6  +  to  cm/e  xup  7  alrrjaaade  pro  axT'qo'eo'de  16  /xet^i; 
/>ro  juevrj 

16:3  —vpZv  7  yap  +  €70;  8  —/cat2  15  ^d^ra  +  7«p  |  Xa;u- 
/3d^€t  pro  \r)iperai     16  —  e7cb 

17:2  6a>cr€t  pro  btoar)  7  e7^cocraj'  />ro  eyvwicav  20  iriffrevovTcov 
pro  Tio-TevaovTOiv     24  Se'Sco/cds  />ro  €'5co/cds 

167 


16  HISTORICAL  AND  LINGUISTIC  STUDIES 

18:8  —6  20  —  rrj  23  daipeis  pro  depets  25  i\pvr]ao.ro  -f-  ovv 
27—0  28  ayovai  pro  ayovviv  \  —ovv  \  Tpafi  pro  Tpofia  32  ep^Wev 
pro  r}p,eKhev     36—6 

19:6  (JTOLvpoxrov2 -\- abrbv  7  //*.  0eoO  vlbv  11  — 61  12  eaurcV 
pro  avrov  13  tovtwv  t&v  \byuv  pro  tovtov  rbv  \byov  |  — tov  \ 
yafiaBa  pro  Tafifiada  16  qyayov  pro  airrjyayov  17  totcov  pro  rbv2 
20  tr.  b  totos  TTJs  7r6Xecos  |  tr.  pajpaiori  eXXT^iari.  25  «Xo7ra  ^f0 
KXcoxa  26  ?5e  ^ro  l8oi»  21  tr.  b  p,a6rjTrjs  avr^v  34  evdews  pro 
evdvs  35  /r.  eariy  airou  36  5e  pro  yap  38  —  b1  39  cos  />f0  totrci 
40  -f"  e^  #w/e  bdoviois 

20:14  —6  15  tr.  fflrjicas  avrbv  16  pa(3ovvi  pro  'Pa/3/3ouja 
18  ci7ra77eXoi;(7-a  ^0  a7ra77eXXoi'(Ta     28  — 61     29  —  6topa     31   — 61 

21:1  pera  +  5e  2  ^os/  ot  add.  uiol  man.  sec.  in  marg.  3  ivi- 
Prjcrav  pro  ave^rjaav     15  —6  'I^coOs     18  eaurcV  />r0  aeavrbv 


168 


•468819 


UNIVERSITY  OF  CALIFORNIA  LIBRARY 


